Selecting a Program Language
Selecting a Programming Language Made Easy
Daniel Salomon & David Rosenblueth
Dept. of Computer Science, U. of Waterloo
Waterloo, Ontario, Canada N2L3G1
With such a large selection of programming languages, it can be difficult to
choose one for a particular project. Reading the manuals to evaluate the
languages is a time-consuming process. On the other hand, most people already
have a fairly good idea of how various automobiles compare. So to assist
those trying to choose a language, we have prepared a chart that matches
programming languages with comparable automobiles.
- ASSEMBLER:
- A Formula I race car. Very fast, but difficult to drive and expensive
to maintain.
- FORTRAN II:
- A Model T Ford. Once it was King of the Road.
-
FORTRAN IV:
- A Model A Ford.
-
FORTRAN 77:
- A six-cylinder Ford Fairlane with standard transmission and no
seat belts.
-
COBOL:
- A delivery van. It's bulky and ugly, but it does the work.
-
BASIC:
- A second-hand Rambler with a rebiult engine and patched upholstery.
Your dad bought it for you to learn to drive. You'll ditch the car
as soon as you can afford a new one.
-
PL/1:
- A Cadillac convertible with automatic transmission, a two-tone
paint job, white-wall tires, chrome exhaust pipes, and fuzzy dice
hanging in the windshield.
-
C:
- A black Firebird, the all-macho car. Comes with optional seat
belts and optional fuzz buster (escape to Assembler).
-
ALGOL 60:
- An Austin Mini. Boy, that's a small car!
-
PASCAL:
- A Volkswagen Beetle. It's small but sturdy. Was once popular with
intellectuals.
-
MODULA-2:
- A Volkswagen Rabbit with a trailer hitch.
-
ALGOL 68:
- An Aston Martin. An impressive car, but not just anyone can drive
it.
LISP: An electric car. It's simple but slow. Seat belts are not
available.
PROLOG/LUCID: Prototype concept-cars.
MAPLE/MACSYMA: An all-terrain vehicle.
FORTH: A go-cart.
LOGO: A kiddie's replica of a Rolls Royce. Comes with a real engine and
a working horn.
APL: A double-decker bus. It takes rows and columns of passengers to
the same place all at the same time, but it drives only in reverse
gear and is instrumented in Greek.
ADA: An army-green Mercedes Benz staff car. Power steering, power
brakes, and automatic transmission are all standard. No other
colors or options are available. If it's good enough for the
generals, it's good enough for you. Manufacturing delays due to
difficulties reading the design specifications are starting to
clear up.